Maya Brenner

Love on the Rocks Ring

A heart ring can be tricky to make chic, but this one doesn’t feel like a themed gift. It’s more of a signet vibe, which we love—and you can wear it year-round without feeling like you’re clinging to February. If she likes one statement ring and then keeps everything else simple, this is an excellent choice.

Lindsey Leigh Jewelry

The Nicole Gemstone Necklace

This is the necklace you put on when you want people to think you have taste without asking questions. The blue stone gives you color right at the face, which is always flattering, and it looks expensive without being obnoxious.

Brilliant Earth

Petite Love Decoded Diamond Bracelet

This one has a little hidden meaning that’s so cute: the diamonds spell LOVE in Morse code, but it just looks like a clean, everyday bracelet on the wrist. It’s a good gift if you want something romantic without putting a literal heart or cheesy words on her body. Quick note: pay attention to the length so it fits the way she likes her bracelets to sit.

Infinity Jewelers USA

Evil Eye Ring Yellow Gold Marquis Cut Emerald

Bethenny loves this Etsy brand and this ring is a great example of why: it’s different without being too much. Emerald is having a moment and the evil eye motif gives you that protective-lucky charm vibe, even if you’re not superstitious.

Platinum Born

Seki Bracelet

Sometimes the smartest jewelry gift is the one she never has to think about. This is simple, easy to layer, and it looks good next to other bracelets without fighting for attention. If you’re shopping and you’re not 100% sure about her style, this is a very low-risk way to get it right.

Spinelli Kilcollin

Pisces 18K Gold and Sterling Silver Ring

Bethenny has this in the mixed metals, which is incredible because you’re never stuck choosing gold or silver. It gives you that stacked-ring look in one shot, so you get impact without having to curate a whole finger situation. If she’s picky about jewelry feeling real on the hand, this is a true investment piece.

Haverhill

Bayberry 7 Gemstone Bracelet

This is for someone who likes a little color but doesn’t want a full tennis bracelet moment. The pink sapphires are subtle enough for everyday, but you still notice them, especially if she wears a watch or keeps her bracelets minimal.

Eriness

Mini Blue and Diamond Ombré Butterfly Pinky Ring

Bethenny has this and wears it constantly. The butterfly has personality, but the stunning ombré stones keep it from feeling childish. If she’s the type who wants a piece that will start conversations and get compliments, this ring does that job.

Aurate

Lab Grown Sapphire Baguette Tennis Bracelet

Bethenny has this in multiple colors and keeps coming back for more, because the quality is insane for the price. The baguette cut gives it a cleaner look than the typical round-stone tennis bracelet, so it feels a little more modern. It’s also one of those pieces you can wear with a sweatshirt and still feel pulled together.

Lizzie Fortunato

14K Gold Confetti Letter Charm

An initial charm can feel a little junior unless it’s done right—and this one is done right. The confetti stones give it that tiny pop of color and sparkle and it turns any plain chain into something that looks like yours. This is a great gift if you know she already has a necklace she never takes off.

Madison James

Lumière Verte Pendant Necklace

If she loves a colored stone, this necklace will get noticed in a good way. It has that “where did you get that?” factor without looking costume-y, and it makes even a simple outfit feel more exciting. It’s also nice if she’s bored of only wearing diamonds and wants something with more personality.

Dana Rebecca Designs

Poppy Rae Pebble Link Bracelet

This is one of those bracelets that makes your whole wrist look done without needing a stack. It has a substantial feel but it’s still easy to live in, which is the point if you’re spending real money on something you’ll wear a lot. If you’re shopping for someone whose style is classic and clean, this is a very safe bet.

Aurate

Diamond Connection Necklace

If you want something romantic that doesn’t scream Valentine’s Day, this is the move. The two linked circles are meaningful without being cheesy and it sits so nicely on the neck. Also great if she already has a jewelry uniform and you’re trying to add something she’ll actually wear, not just admire.

Goldhaus

Edge Earrings

These are a stunning alternative to the daintier earrings you tend to see people wear when they get dressed up. You can choose the shape, which is helpful if she has a strong preference, and they’re special-occasion worthy without being one-night-only. The kind of piece you’ll still be happy you own years from now.